2025 NFL Season

Draft Kit
Week
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

🎯 You're viewing showcase recommendations only

Get full access to all 371 player recommendations and expert analysis from 375 sources.

Week 5 Advice

Sup dude? This week I combed through 375 shitty fantasy football articles and videos so you dont have to and pulled out 3006 pieces of bullshit advice. We're covering 371 players & teams here. You can thank me later... maybe consider buying me a beer?

Last updated 11 days ago (10/5/2025 7:12 PM PT).

Position
QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
Advice
Start
Sit
Add
Drop

Kyle Pitts

Start4

Pitts is catching a steady number of passes and scoring, so start him whenever he’s playing. He has a bye in Week 5, though, so bench him that week — if your league is big and he’s available, grab him off waivers. Want 6 more details?

Rico Dowdle

Start5

If Hubbard is out, start Dowdle — he’s been getting most of the carries and Miami is really weak against the run. If Hubbard might play, pick Dowdle up now as a short-term starter but be ready to move him once Hubbard returns. Want 33 more details?

Mixed consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 40% in 33 sources updated 10 days ago

Consensus from multiple experts: With Chuba Hubbard ruled out or listed day-to-day with a calf injury, Dowdle projects as Carolina’s lead back and is startable for Week 5. Strong supporting evidence: Dowdle has recent bell‑cow-level work (23–26 carries, 47 snaps, 200+ rushing yards and multiple TDs in recent fill-in work), consistent short‑yardage/goal‑line usage (high red‑zone carry share), and increasing snap share (reported 30–40% in recent weeks). Matchup is favorable — Miami ranks poorly vs. the run (third‑most rushing yards allowed per game and low run‑stop win rate). Expert consensus across ESPN, RotoBaller, FantasyPros, The Sporting News, CBS, Yahoo and others recommends starting Dowdle if Hubbard is out and adding him in most leagues otherwise. Risk/limitations: his long‑term ceiling falls if/when Hubbard returns, so consider selling high or treating him as a high‑upside short‑term RB2; monitor Hubbard’s injury status if not yet officially ruled out. Recommendation: START him (RB2/FLEX) this week if Hubbard is inactive; otherwise ADD/monitor as the primary handcuff and potential near‑term starter.

10/06 Start (100%) Starter with Chuba Hubbard out; huge workload (23 carries, 206 yards, TD) and favorable upcoming matchup vs. Dallas. Article calls him a locked-in RB2 with RB1 upside.
10/06 Start (100%) If Chuba Hubbard is still out in Week 6, Dowdle profiles as a solid RB2 after his 202-yard, three-touchdown game.
10/06 Add (100%) Took over with Chuba Hubbard down, produced 202 rushing yards and 32.4 PPR; available in ~60% of leagues and projects as a solid RB2 if Hubbard remains out.
10/06 Add (71%) Exploded for 206 rushing and 234 total yards with Hubbard out — immediate add in most formats and startable while he maintains volume.
10/06 Add (100%) Started in place of injured Chuba Hubbard and produced a 200-yard rushing game (26 touches) — demonstrated lead-back ability; article explicitly recommends grabbing him off waivers (58% rostered).
10/06 Add (100%) Recommended to add in deeper leagues if Hubbard misses more time — provides RB2/flex depth with potential to handle workload.
10/06 Start (100%) Projected to start with Chuba Hubbard out and has a matchup vs Miami, which ranks poorly vs the run; has prior starting experience and decent efficiency (4.6 YPC in 2024).
10/06 Start Expected to assume lead-back duties with Hubbard out and faces a Miami defense allowing the third-most rushing yards per game — good Week 5 start or add.
10/06 Trade Given the massive usage spike and limited long-term ceiling (when Hubbard returns), owners can consider selling high for a meaningful return while his value peaks.
10/06 Add Exploded for 23 carries, 206 yards and a TD while filling in (47 snaps). Strong immediate upside and should be rostered as a high-value handcuff/WW add.
10/06 Add (100%) Filled in as Panthers' RB1 with Chuba Hubbard out, 26 touches for 234 scrimmage yards and a TD in Week 5. Would be main handcuff and flex option if Hubbard misses more time.
10/06 Start Called a safer volume play — expected to get a lot of work (full reign) and faces a defense poor vs the run (Miami).
10/06 Start (56%) Should assume RB1 role in Carolina with Chuba Hubbard out (calf); Hubbard has been seeing 15+ touches in games, so Dowdle projects for a high-touch role and the Dolphins matchup has recently been friendly to RBs (three straight RBs with 16+ PPR).
10/04 Start (100%) Chuba Hubbard ruled out with a calf injury, making Dowdle the lead back; Dolphins rank 28th in run stop win rate and have allowed significant fantasy production to RBs. Dowdle has historically produced when seeing 15+ touches.
10/04 Add (100%) Chuba Hubbard is dealing with a calf injury that could reduce his workload; Dowdle stands to see increased snap share and touches in the Panthers backfield for Week 5. Worth adding from waivers for immediate depth/handcuff upside and possible start if Hubbard is ruled out.
10/04 Monitor Mentioned in connection with Hubbard’s calf injury — suggests Dowdle could see increased opportunity if Hubbard is limited or sidelined.
10/04 Monitor (100%) Mentioned as a fantasy tip/replacement if Chuba Hubbard is OUT — conditional pickup/start depending on Hubbard's status.
10/04 Start Frequently called as the recommended second flex/RB option this week — expected workload with Chuba Hubbard out/doubtful; good touchdown upside and immediate role in Dallas/NE (?) per the discussion.
10/04 Start Chuba Hubbard will not play, increasing Dowdle's role in Carolina's backfield; recommended to start over Chase Brown this week.
10/04 Add (100%) Chuba Hubbard missed practice and is officially ruled out for Week 5; text highlights Dowdle's fantasy value rising with Hubbard missing practices, signaling more snaps/touches.
10/04 Start (100%) Next man up in Carolina's backfield with Hubbard out; expected to draw the starting workload and additional touches in Week 5 vs. Miami.
10/04 Start (100%) Chuba Hubbard is out (calf), and Dowdle was signed to slide in as a near-lateral replacement; has shown ability to handle 20+ touches and contributes in the passing game with goal-to-go role — favorable matchup vs Miami's poor run defense.
10/04 Add (100%) Becomes the immediate lead back with Hubbard out, earning significant snap share and is a plug-and-play RB2 in Week 5 — must-add in 12-team leagues.
10/03 Monitor (74%) Chuba Hubbard is day-to-day; if Hubbard misses Dowdle would be a borderline No.2 with increased work — monitor injury status and act if Hubbard out.
10/03 Add Would assume lead role in Carolina's backfield if Chuba Hubbard is unable to play due to his calf injury — worth adding as RB depth or handcuff insurance.
10/03 Start (100%) If Hubbard is ruled out, Dowdle is expected to handle lead-back duties and absorb most rushing work for Carolina, making him a startable option in that scenario.
10/03 Add (100%) If Chuba Hubbard misses Week 5 with the worsening calf injury, Dowdle should see a significant workload and would profile as an RB2/FLEX against Miami. He is available in most leagues, making him an obvious pickup for Hubbard owners.
10/03 Add Recommended adding Rico Dowdle immediately if you roster Chuba Hubbard — handcuff with immediate upside if Hubbard is out.
10/01 Add Taking work away from Chuba Hubbard and has shown recent touches and a touchdown; article recommends stashing in all leagues for 1% FAB as handcuff/lottery ticket.
10/01 Monitor (100%) Chuba Hubbard is day-to-day with a calf injury; if Hubbard misses Week 5 Dowdle would be a borderline No.2 RB and has already been taking work away in recent weeks.
10/01 Add (100%) Increasing role (30–40% of snaps recent weeks) with short-yardage and goal-line work; could be a flex option if he continues ~10 touches per game.
10/01 Add After Chuba Hubbard showed up on the injury report, hosts urged adding Rico Dowdle immediately — immediate volume/handcuff upside in Miami.
09/29 Add (100%) Carolina’s RB2 with consistent snap counts, strong red-zone usage (75% of carries inside 5-yard line) — reliable handcuff and potential red-zone flex if Hubbard misses time.

Najee Harris

Drop6

Najee Harris tore his Achilles and is out for the season, so take him off your active roster and drop him to free a spot for someone who’s playing now. Only keep him if your league lets you stash injured players or keeps players across years for future use. Want 2 more details?

Jameson Williams

Start6

He’s getting more targets and is the team’s main deep-ball guy against a Cincinnati defense that struggles to cover receivers, so he could break a big play this week. But he can be great or invisible, so only start him if you’re okay with that risk; if you need steady points, sit him or try to swap him for a safer option. Want 9 more details?

Moderate consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 56% in 9 sources updated 10 days ago

Consensus of analysts points to clear upside this week: Williams has seen a usage uptick (season-high 8 targets, team-high air yards/30% air share in W4) and a very high aDOT (~20.5–21 yards), marking him as the team’s primary deep threat. He faces a Bengals secondary that’s struggled vs. WRs (roughly 27th in pass DVOA / 7th‑worst vs WRs) and generates low pressure—matchup and schematic leverage that should lead to at least one explosive play. That combination makes Williams a high-upside WR3/FLEX start with plausible 20+ point ceiling. Risks: highly inconsistent week-to-week (boom-or-bust profile), several games with low target volume and low floor; if you need a reliable floor or have no bench depth, consider benching or trading for steadier WRs per Matt Okada’s advice. Overall: start in Week 5 if you can tolerate volatility and want upside; consider trading if you can get a safer asset at fair value.

10/06 Sit Very low target volume in a favorable matchup (only 1 target in this game) and four games under double-digit fantasy points this season. Low trust — move to bench/stream other options.
10/04 Start (100%) Has seen multiple deep-air-yard targets and faces a Bengals defense that has allowed numerous 25+ yard completions; projection for at least one explosive play given matchup and Williams' role as deep threat.
10/04 Start (100%) Uptick in volume and huge downfield usage (aDOT ~21 yards) with several near-misses; facing a Bengals defense that is 7th‑worst vs WRs and bottom‑5 in pressure rate, creating big-play upside—can hit 20+ fantasy points.
10/04 Start Favored to produce at least one big splash play; Bengals secondary ranks poorly (27th in pass DVOA) and have allowed a 22+ yard reception in every game — high upside for Williams long play.
10/04 Start (100%) Seeing increased target share and a 20.5-yard aDOT — boom-bust but faces Bengals who allow a high explosive-play rate to WRs; good WR3/FLEX play for Week 5.
10/03 Start (100%) Williams' average depth of target has increased to 21 yards (2nd-highest). Tape shows big-play usage and favorable upcoming matchup vs Bengals (struggling vs WRs and poor pressure), making him a high-upside start for Week 5.
10/03 Add Massive air yards and target share (team-high 30% in week 4) despite poor box score; classic buy-low/start-this-week spot against a weak Bengals secondary — usage indicates big upside.
09/29 Start Season-high eight targets indicates growing involvement; expected to bounce back as a solid WR3/flex in Week 5 against Cincinnati.
09/29 Trade (100%) Boom-or-bust profile (huge scoring days tied to long plays, but otherwise inconsistent); advised to trade for steadier assets if you can get value (examples: Emeka Egbuka, Marvin Harrison Jr., Ricky Pearsall).

Malik Nabers

Drop7

He tore his ACL and is out for the season, so he won’t score for you this year. If your league has a special injured spot, move him there; otherwise free his active spot for a healthy player — but if you play a league where you keep players from year to year, hold onto him instead of dropping him. Want 28 more details?

Moderate consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 63% in 28 sources updated 10 days ago

Consensus reporting (multiple outlets including Gridiron Experts, CBS, Yahoo, Sporting News, RotoBaller, etc.) confirms Malik Nabers sustained a season-ending torn ACL in Week 4 and has been placed on injured reserve. This removes his fantasy value for the remainder of the 2025 season. In redraft/shallow formats the roster spot should be freed for a healthy replacement; if your league supports an IR slot, place him there instead of occupying an active roster spot. For dynasty/keeper formats he retains long-term value and should be stashed/held or used as a rebuild trade chip rather than dropped. Recommendation prioritizes redraft action (drop/IR) while noting dynasty exceptions.

10/06 Sit Placed on injured reserve and out for the season — sit/drop as roster decisions dictate.
10/04 Drop (100%) Article states Nabers is done for the year (season-ending injury) — owners must free the roster spot and replace him.
10/03 Drop Season-ending injury reported; remove/drop or place on IR in dynasty/season-long formats.
10/03 Drop Reported out for the season with a torn ACL — season-ending injury makes him a hold on rosters impractical for most fantasy teams.
10/03 Drop (100%) Article states Malik Nabers is out for the season with a torn ACL. That is actionable roster news—place him on IR or drop if you need the roster spot.
10/01 Trade Nabers suffered a torn ACL and will miss the season; the write-up advises he is a 'solid trade target for dynasty managers looking to rebuild,' making him actionable in dynasty trade strategies.
10/01 Drop Sustained season-ending torn ACL in Week 4; article says to drop in redraft leagues.
10/01 Drop (100%) Sustained a season-ending ACL tear and was placed on injured reserve; will miss the remainder of the 2025 season, so he's not roster-usable in redraft formats.
10/01 Drop (100%) Nabers is out for the season with a torn ACL — in redraft leagues you should drop or place him on IR to free a roster spot; in dynasty, place on IR but keep long term value.
10/01 Drop (5%) Article states Malik Nabers is out for the season with a torn ACL — season-ending injury removes his fantasy value, so rostered teams should drop or IR him if possible.
10/01 Drop Sustained season-ending torn ACL — no fantasy value for the remainder of the season; frees roster spot for productive additions.
09/30 Drop Sustained a season-ending torn ACL and is out for the season — remove from active fantasy rosters in redraft formats.
09/30 Drop (100%) Reported torn ACL ends his season; drop in redraft leagues. Exception: in keeper leagues do not drop due to long-term upside.
09/30 Drop (100%) Article reports a season-ending knee injury — if rostered in shallow leagues, move him to IR/drop to free roster spot; he's out for the season.
09/30 Drop (100%) Out for the season with a torn ACL — no fantasy value for the remainder of the year in redraft formats; free up roster/IR spot.
09/29 Drop (100%) Sustained a season-ending torn ACL in Week 4; will miss the rest of 2025, so he won't provide fantasy value this season.
09/29 Drop (100%) Malik Nabers was carted off and confirmed to have a torn ACL that will end his season; he will be unavailable for the rest of 2025 and should be removed from active fantasy rosters (or placed on IR if your league allows).
09/29 Monitor (100%) Reported suspected torn ACL; likely season-ending but confirmation pending — advise against immediately dropping in redraft until official confirmation, but treat as long-term injury risk.
09/29 Drop (100%) Confirmed torn ACL in left knee in Week 4 — season-ending injury that removes fantasy value for the rest of the season. Rosters should clear the spot for an active replacement or waiver add.
09/29 Monitor (100%) Suffered a torn ACL and will miss time, but remains young and is still an elite Dynasty asset — hold/monitor rather than drop or trade in dynasty leagues.
09/29 Monitor (100%) Left Week 4 with a right knee injury feared to be a torn ACL; MRI pending — likely season-ending and managers should plan replacements.
09/29 Monitor (100%) Suffered a significant knee injury that is thought to be a torn ACL; immediate fantasy action is to monitor his recovery and remove him from your active lineup/consider IR until status is confirmed.
09/29 Drop Suffered a torn ACL in Week 4 and will miss the remainder of the season; no reason to roster him while injured.
09/29 Drop Sustained a torn ACL and is out for the season — clear season-ending injury means roster spot should be freed for a healthy replacement.
09/29 Drop (100%) Sustained a torn right ACL and will miss the remainder of the 2025 season; unavailable to contribute and will be out for recovery through 2025. In redraft leagues you should remove him from active roster/consider drop or place on IR. In dynasty keep only for long-term value if desired.
09/29 Drop (100%) Sustained a season-ending torn ACL, per the report. He will be unavailable for the rest of the season, so in redraft leagues he should be dropped (place on IR if your league supports it in keeper/dynasty formats).
09/29 Drop (100%) Article reports season-ending torn ACL. For redraft rosters this is effectively season-ending; free up roster spot unless you’re in dynasty and want to stash.
09/29 Drop (100%) Sustained a season-ending torn ACL — in redraft leagues this is a rosterable long-term injury; consider dropping or moving to IR/IR-designated spot to free roster space.

Rachaad White

Start6

If Bucky Irving is out, Rachaad White should get most of the carries and catches, so put him in your lineup. Seattle lets running backs catch a lot of passes which helps him, though he could still split time with Sean Tucker and Seattle is tough to run on. Want 37 more details?

Moderate consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 44% in 37 sources updated 10 days ago

Strong consensus: if Bucky Irving is out or inactive (many outlets cite a foot/ankle issue and some report him in a boot), Rachaad White projects to inherit the bulk of Tampa Bay’s backfield work — early-down/goal-line snaps plus passing-down usage. Multiple analysts project a 14–18+ touch floor and snap share approaching ~70%, noting his 2023 starter experience and early‑season usage (example line: 23 rushes for 108 yards and 9 catches in prior work). Matchup boosts PPR value: Seattle has allowed the most RB receptions/receiving yards, which elevates White’s floor as a pass-catcher even in a tough rushing matchup. Risk factors (committee with Sean Tucker, tough run defense) are acknowledged, but the volume/opportunity and consistent expert agreement make him startable in most formats (especially PPR) while Irving remains out.

10/06 Start (100%) Named the lead back for Week 5 with Bucky Irving out; expected to receive the vast majority of carries and offers pass-catching upside — projects as an RB2 this week.
10/06 Start Set to take the bulk of carries for Tampa Bay with Irving out — clear Week 5 RB option.
10/06 Start Host recommended Rashad White as a flex/start alongside David Montgomery (specifically said he'd play Montgomery and White).
10/06 Start Started in place of B. Irving (inactive) and produced 14 carries for 41 yards & 2 TDs plus 4 catches for 30 yards. Strong pass-catching upside and favorable Week 6 matchup (49ers run-friendly). Recommended as an RB2/top-15 start while Irving is out.
10/06 Start Multiple leanings toward Rashad White over Chase Brown in RB/start choices — hosts favored White for floor/role this week.
10/06 Start (56%) Expected to start with Bucky Irving dealing with a foot injury; Seahawks allow a lot of receptions and receiving yards to running backs — White has RB1 upside in this matchup.
10/04 Start Although the rushing matchup is tough, Rashad White projects to be a factor in the passing game with Baker Mayfield; Seattle has allowed the most receiving yards to running backs, making White a strong PPR play this week.
10/04 Start (100%) Bucky Irving ruled out with a foot injury, putting White in line for workhorse workload similar to 2023 (high carry share and target share), making him an RB1 in most formats while Irving remains out.
10/04 Start Listed as part of Tampa Bay's backfield rotation with Irving out; expected to see increased volume and early-down work against Seattle.
10/04 Monitor (100%) Listed as a recommended fantasy replacement if Bucky Irving is OUT — actionable conditional start/consideration depending on Irving's status.
10/04 Start If Bucky Irving misses time, the analyst expects Rachaad White to be the bell-cow for a week or two — short-term start/add on waivers.
10/04 Start Bucky Irvin likely out and Mike Evans status uncertain; Seattle allows the most receiving yards and second-most receptions to opposing RBs — White projects to see pass-game work and upside for a big week.
10/04 Start Multiple recommendations in the text to start Rashad White as a safe RB/flex in PPR given injuries (Bucky/Chuba out or limited) and Seattle’s vulnerability to RB receiving yards — projected target share and floor make him a reliable play.
10/04 Start With Bucky Irving out, hosts expected White to take high‑leverage touches and be a volume-based fantasy starter (top‑24 projection) thanks to his pass-catch role.
10/04 Start Bucky Irving is not expected to play, leaving White to handle Tampa Bay's backfield and he excels in pass protection; the backfield work and expected passing-game shift make him startable in all formats.
10/04 Start (100%) With Bucky Irving out, White has a clear path to an RB2 role this week and should be started, especially in standard/single-RB formats.
10/03 Add (100%) Primary backup to Irving and would see expanded duties if Irving misses time. Has 4.7 YPC this season and involvement as a pass-catching outlet (useful in PPR). Logged 6 carries and 4 receptions for 46 yards in the loss to Philadelphia.
10/03 Start (100%) Projected committee with Sean Tucker if Bucky Irving is out; White expected to handle ~14–18 total touches and is identified as the only viable FLEX option.
10/03 Start (74%) Could be a true No.2 if Bucky Irving misses; has receiving upside which matters vs Seahawks who allow a lot of RB catches — should be flex in PPR formats.
10/03 Start (100%) With Bucky Irving out, White is expected to see a larger role (historically played every game and was trusted); projected snap/share could approach ~70% of backfield work, making him a start in most formats.
10/03 Add (100%) If Bucky Irving is unavailable, White would absorb more work in a backfield already thin from injuries—worth adding as immediate depth/handcuff and likely startable if Irving is out.
10/03 Monitor Could see a larger role if Bucky Irving is unavailable; author says to monitor his status.
10/03 Add If Bucky Irving is out, White will inherit significant volume and target share in the Bucs backfield; playable as an RB3/flex despite a tough matchup vs Seattle.
10/03 Start (100%) Bucky Irving appears to have a significant foot/ankle injury (spotted in a boot), likely knocking him out and handing White a full-time workload; very cheap DFS price ($4,700) makes him a top freeroll FLEX option.
10/03 Start Recommended starting Rashaad (Rashard) White this week over JCM — expected increased role/usage this week.
10/03 Add If Bucky Irving is inactive/limited, White has a clear path to increased touches vs Seattle; add in deeper formats or start if Bucky is out.
10/03 Start (100%) Text states White would likely handle the bulk of the work if Irving sits. White already has early-season touches and 23 rushes for 108 yards plus 9 catches; proven starter in 2023. Start him in Week 5 if Irving is out or limited.
10/01 Monitor (100%) Mentioned as a higher priority than Carter/Demercado if Bucky Irving misses time — actionable conditional pickup if Irving’s status changes.
10/01 Add (100%) Bucky Irving appears likely to miss time with a foot sprain; White has starting experience in TB’s backfield and is a proven pass-catcher (useful in PPR). The article identifies White as the best pickup option and notes his recent usage (23 rushes/108 yards, 9 catches/34 yards).
10/01 Start (100%) If Bucky Irving misses or is limited, White would be the No.2 RB and take on more passing-down work; Seahawks allow the most receptions/receiving yards to RBs, boosting White's value in PPR formats.
10/01 Start Only start if Bucky Irving misses; projected low-end starter with some passing-game work if Irving is out.
10/01 Add Hosts recommended Rashad White as the immediate pickup this week (smaller window but immediate upside) due to injuries in his backfield.
10/01 Start If Bucky Irving is inactive, White projects to be the workhorse and should be treated as a solid RB2 with pass-catching and goal-line upside.
09/30 Add (100%) With Bucky Irving banged up, White would be next in line in Tampa Bay’s backfield — worth picking up if Irving misses time or for depth/handcuff value.
09/30 Add Named as a good fill-in if Bucky Irving misses time with an ankle issue; valuable handcuff depth in Tampa Bay backfield.
09/30 Add (100%) RotoBaller explicitly advises picking him up immediately if available because Bucky Irving's status is uncertain; provides immediate backfield value if Irving misses time.
09/29 Add (100%) Tampa Bay’s RB2 with growing snap share and increased route work; add as handcuff to Bucky Irving and because Irving has an undisclosed injury that could elevate White’s role.

D'Andre Swift

Sit3

D'Andre Swift is on the Bears' Week 5 bye — don't start him this week. Try to trade him now since he's been inconsistent and might lose playing time after the bye; if you can't, bench him and watch his snaps, touches, and targets after the break before using him in close matchups. Want 8 more details?

Unclear consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 25% in 8 sources updated 14 days ago

Short-term: Swift is on the Bears' Week 5 bye — do not start him this week. Mid-term: multiple analysts recommend selling/trading him due to inefficient production (underperforming expected fantasy points), shaky job security with potential offensive retool after the bye, and middling RB2 upside despite volume and receiving work. One analyst projects increased passing-game involvement under HC Ben Johnson (PPR upside), but that is speculative and conflicts with the consensus to sell. Recommendation: Sit for Week 5 (bye) and actively explore trade offers now — prioritize deals that convert his current volume-based, volatile profile into more consistent upside. If you can’t move him, bench and monitor snap share, touches, and target share closely in the games after the bye before starting him in close matchups.

10/01 Monitor (100%) Mentioned alongside Barkley as having a 'disappointing start' — implies possible downgrade in fantasy reliability; monitor usage, touches, and matchup before lineup decisions.
10/01 Trade Not performing to expectations and his role/job security in the offense is uncertain despite overall volume; recommend selling while you can rather than investing long-term.
10/01 Start (100%) Projected to play a larger role in the Bears' passing game under HC Ben Johnson as a PPR check-down target for Caleb Williams.
09/30 Trade Author explicitly recommends not holding him — describes Swift as inefficient and a middling RB2, and predicts potential negative impact from offensive changes; advises trading him rather than keeping a low-floor player.
09/30 Sit (100%) Article lists D'Andre Swift as on a Week 5 bye and explicitly tells managers to replace him before their matchup.
09/30 Trade Swift lacks trustworthy production despite high-volume offense and receiving-chance profile; job security is shaky and he’s underperforming his expected fantasy points, so trade while you can — a suggested target trade is for Woody Marks based on perceived upside.
09/30 Sell Described as an inefficient, volume-based RB2 with limited ceiling; Bears offense is likely to be retooled after the bye and Swift's role/efficiency may not improve — trade while you can for upside elsewhere.
09/29 Sit (100%) Detroit on Week 5 bye per article; do not start Swift for Week 5.

Tyreek Hill

Drop5

He tore multiple knee ligaments and had surgery, so he won’t play again this season. If your league has a place for injured players, move him there; otherwise drop him so the roster spot goes to someone active — in leagues where you keep players for next year you can hold or try to trade him while he’s injured. Want 18 more details?

Mixed consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 44% in 18 sources updated 10 days ago

Strong, consistent reporting from multiple reputable outlets (CBS, ESPN, Yahoo, The Sporting News, RotoBaller, etc.) indicates Tyreek Hill suffered a catastrophic knee injury (multiple torn ligaments including ACL / dislocation) that required surgery and will sideline him for the remainder of the season. Given the season-ending nature of the injury, Hill will provide no fantasy value this year in redraft formats; carrying him ties up a roster spot that should be used by active players. If your league supports IR, place him on IR; otherwise drop to free roster space. For dynasty/keeper leagues, consider stashing if you have room or trading him while injured for value — but for redraft, drop. Note some outlets advised monitoring after a positive update that no additional procedure is needed, but that does not contradict the season-ending diagnosis or change immediate fantasy utility. Targets and snaps will be redistributed (e.g., Waller, Malik Washington), so prioritize active pass-catchers.

10/06 Sit Placed on season-ending IR — out for the season, sit/drop depending on roster construction.
10/04 Drop Text states Tyreek Hill tore an ACL and the analyst explicitly calls him droppable in redraft leagues.
10/04 Drop (100%) Article reports Hill is done for the year (season-ending) — fantasy managers should remove/replace him and prioritize healthy receivers.
10/03 Sit (100%) Out for the foreseeable future with a knee injury; with him out, Redzone targets shift (notably to Darren Waller) — don’t plan to start Hill until cleared.
10/03 Drop Season-ending injury noted in the article — drop or IR in season-long formats.
10/03 Monitor Article notes Tyreek Hill went down with an injury, which significantly impacts Miami's offense; his status is uncertain and should be tracked before finalizing lineups.
10/01 Monitor (60%) Suffered a gruesome injury; managers should monitor injury updates and consider targeting backups/secondary options (e.g., Malik Washington) while Hill's status clears up.
10/01 Drop (100%) Suffered a catastrophic knee injury with multiple ligament tears (including ACL) and will not play again in 2025; long-term availability and effectiveness are in serious doubt.
10/01 Drop (100%) Sustained season-ending knee injury per report — effectively out for 2025; in redraft leagues this clears a roster spot (dynasty teams should stash or evaluate trade value).
09/30 Monitor (100%) Headline references ‘fantasy fallout for Dolphins amid Hill injury’ — indicates Hill has an injury issue that could alter playing time and redistribute targets; monitor his status and corresponding usage changes for Dolphins' pass-catchers.
09/30 Monitor (100%) Text reports 'Hill injury a "huge blow" to Dolphins offense' — indicates an injury that could affect availability and fantasy production. Owners should track his injury status/official designation and be prepared to bench him if ruled out or limited.
09/30 Drop Reported as out for the year; season-ending absence makes him unusable in redraft lineups — drop or move to IR/IR-eligible if possible in your league.
09/30 Monitor (100%) Note: 'Tyreek Hill will not need an additional procedure on knee' — positive medical update, but monitor week-to-week status before starting.
09/30 Drop Suffered a season-ending knee injury (torn multiple ligaments, ACL, dislocation) and will miss the remainder of the season; roster spot is best used on active players or placed on IR if your league supports it.
09/30 Drop (100%) Season-ending dislocated knee with multiple torn ligaments — out for the 2025 season; unless in a keeper league, he can be dropped to free roster spot and get usable assets.
09/30 Drop (100%) Suffered catastrophic knee injury requiring surgery and will miss the rest of the season; long-term availability is uncertain and he won't provide fantasy value this year.
09/30 Drop (100%) Suffered a gruesome knee injury with several torn ligaments including a torn ACL; had surgery and will focus on rehab with goal to be ready next season — effectively out for the remainder of the current season for fantasy purposes.
09/29 Start (100%) Projected to see 6-8 targets per game, has 100+ yards in two of his last three vs the Jets; Jets secondary has allowed 489 receiving yards to WRs (9th-worst). Article specifically recommends Hill OVER 64.5 receiving yards.

Zach Charbonnet

Sit4

Bench him this week — he’s sharing carries with Kenneth Walker and Tampa Bay is tough against running backs, so he probably won’t get enough touches to help you. Keep him as a backup if Walker gets hurt, or trade him if you can get someone with a clearer role. Want 11 more details?

Mixed consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 32% in 11 sources updated 10 days ago

Consensus and evidence point to benching Charbonnet this week. Most experts flag him as a timeshare/rotational back (returned with ~45% snaps, 12 carries) behind Kenneth Walker III, with limited weekly upside and TD-dependence. Matchup is tough — Tampa Bay has allowed the fewest rushing yards to RBs and limits YPC (2.9), further depressing touchdown and volume upside. A minority of analysts call him a start if active or for red-zone/TDDP upside, but those are conditional cases (Walker unavailable or you need touchdown upside). Recommendation: bench him in standard lineups, hold on the roster as an injury-contingent RB1/handcuff, and monitor Walker’s health and usage splits. Consider trading him if you can get value for a higher-upside player. Sources synthesized: fantasypros consensus, NFL Fantasy, Rotoworld, Karabell, RotoBaller, Gridiron Experts, others.

10/06 Sit Advised benching Charbonnet in favor of RJ Harvey or Michael Carter due to split workload in that backfield and lower upside/volume.
10/03 Sit (100%) Described as a cannonball-based RB3 with lower upside compared to Kenneth Walker III; not a reliable RB2 option.
10/03 Sit (100%) Returned from injury but split work (45% snaps, 12 carries) and faces a Buccaneers defense that has allowed the fewest rushing yards to RBs (2.9 YPC); Kenneth Walker III should be prioritized over Charbonnet this week.
10/03 Monitor Advised not to trade Charbonnet for Stefon Diggs — value as an injury-contingent RB1 (if Kenneth Walker III goes down) makes him worth holding.
10/01 Drop Panel repeatedly suggested moving off Charbonnet as a tradable/drop candidate — lowest upside among that player group and preferred to target Harvey/Marks instead.
10/01 Start (100%) Slight edge in red-zone usage and passing-game involvement; has been effective and is the preferred Seahawks option by a small margin — weekly flex/start candidate.
10/01 Sit Rotational role with fewer snaps; not preferred over Kenneth Walker — limited upside this week.
10/01 Sit Receiving some goal-line carries but split remains even; graded shaky flex — not a reliable start compared to primary starters.
10/01 Monitor Seattle remains a committee with Kenneth Walker holding the lead in touches and efficiency; Charbonnet offers more receiving routes but fewer carries and projects as a TD-dependent flex option rather than an every-week RB1. Start only if you need touchdown upside or Walker is unavailable.
09/29 Start (5%) Listed as expected to play on Thursday night — if active, you should start him rather than benching him for a questionable alternative.
09/29 Start (46%) Seahawks are using a timeshare but both backs are getting ample touches; Charbonnet outscored Walker in Week 4 and is playable/starts in most lineups this week.

Quentin Johnston

Start8

He’s getting most of the passes and has had 70+ yards and a touchdown every game, so I’d start him this week against Washington. Only trade him if someone offers a lot or you really need help elsewhere, since an offensive line injury could make the passing game tougher. Want 21 more details?

Strong consensus from highly credible sources. Overall confidence 67% in 21 sources updated 10 days ago

Strong expert consensus to start Johnston — nearly every analyst grades him as a weekly start based on heavy target share (roughly 9–13 targets/game, ~32% team target share), large air-yard share (~60% Week 4), consistent WR1-level production (70+ yards in every game, 4 TDs in 4 games), and clear role as Justin Herbert’s primary deep and red-zone threat. Matchups cited (Washington/Commanders) are favorable against deep threats and allow above-average fantasy production to WRs. Primary risks noted: offensive line injury concerns (Joe Alt) that could affect pass protection and a fantasypros hold/sell-high viewpoint for managers who need positional assets. Overall risk/reward favors starting him as a weekly WR/WR2 with upside as a WR1; consider selling only if you have immediate team needs and can get premium value.

10/06 Start (100%) Season-low 6.9 but expected to rebound in Week 6 with a positive matchup vs the Miami defense — recommended start for Week 6.
10/06 Start Host explicitly picked Quentin Johnston as one of his two wide receivers in lineup suggestions — listed as a start option.
10/06 Start Hosts recommended starting Johnston (favored vs Commanders); ranked just ahead of Terry McLaurin and seen as a good play vs that secondary.
10/04 Start (100%) Chargers have an elite trio of receivers and Johnston has been targeted on explosive plays; Chargers face a Commanders defense that allows the seventh-most fantasy points per game to quarterbacks, so Johnston should rebound.
10/04 Start (100%) Author says Johnston 'finally looks legit' and along with Keenan Allen remains a solid play for Sunday against the Commanders; start him this week.
10/04 Trade Breakout early-season production (four TDs in four games) creates peak trade value — consider selling high for positional needs, especially if you don't rely on him weekly and offensive line injuries (Joe Alt) are a potential risk.
10/03 Start High per-game production (over 17 FPPG) with consistent 30+ yard plays; favorable matchup vs Washington, who allows the 8th-most fantasy points to WRs.
10/03 Start (100%) Posting consistent WR1-level production with a high floor (never under 71 yards) and consistent long plays—must-start option.
10/03 Start (100%) Recognized as the Chargers' No. 1 receiver with at least 14.9 PPR in each of first four games, four TDs, 7+ targets per game; Chargers favorable matchup vs Washington.
10/03 Start (100%) Leads the Chargers in targets and is third overall in the NFL; Chargers are heavily passing under Justin Herbert, producing consistent volume and upside.
10/03 Start Called the most reliable Chargers target this week against a tough Washington pass rush; recommended starter among Chargers receivers.
10/03 Hold Third-year breakout looks real with continued improvement; keep him but not necessarily buy aggressively at higher cost.
10/01 Add (100%) Surprising early-season production (WR4) and looks to have leapt into a featured role — recommended to add if available.
10/01 Start (55%) Called a blistering hot start and clear DFS value — averaging 19.9 PPR per game, high target volume and TDs; author explicitly says to 'stack him with Herbert without hesitation.'
10/01 Start (100%) Leads Chargers in target and air-yard share and is second in end-zone targets; consistent production and strong deep threat. Washington has allowed the 9th-most receiving yards and struggles vs. deep ball.
10/01 Start Surprising breakout — playing very well early and sustaining hot-tier production.
10/01 Start Strong early-season connection with Justin Herbert — should be started unless you are stacked at WR; treating him as a weekly starter.
09/30 Start Emerging as the Chargers' top target — high target share (~32%) and large air-yard share (~60%) in Week 4. Trend shows him taking over lead-receiver role vs Lad McConkey.
09/30 Start (100%) Led Chargers with 8 catches on 13 targets for 98 yards and scored his fourth TD; has emerged as Justin Herbert's top big-play target and faces a Washington pass defense that has struggled.
09/29 Start (100%) Second 20+ point game of season, heavy target share (13 targets), consistent touchdown production (3 of 4 games). Upside WR3/Flex for Week 5.
09/29 Start (100%) Averaging 9.3 targets per game, 70+ yards in all four contests and four TDs across four weeks — identified as WR4 on season and unlikely to fall out of WR2 range; should be started.